I originally got this recipe from a friend, who graciously lets me "borrow" her copies of Everyday Food every summer when we spend a long weekend up north. (I finally caved and got my own subscription, only to get a notice in the mail that the magazine is being discontinued and they're sending me a substitute subscription instead. I just got rid of 14 years' worth of complicated cooking magazines so I'm not terribly excited about this. But I'm also too disorganized to actually find the notice and cancel altogether. I suppose there's a lesson in here, something like Clean Off Your Desk Already. Whatever.)
It's a Christmas favorite, because it's fast and easy and keeps forever and travels well, and also gives you a way to use up all the random broken candy canes that have fallen off the tree. I made it for my daughter's holiday party at school and was mobbed by 4th graders when I walked through the door. "We love the fudge!" "This is the best thing I ever tasted!" "Please make this for every party!" and the real clincher: "You are the awesomest cooker ever!"
If you know nothing else about me, it's insightful (and possibly useful) to know that I am a slut for praise about my cooking. Compliment me and I will cook for you again and again. Invite me to dinner once in a while and you have an invitation for life. (There's an episode of "Friends" about this, btw - Monica and the chocolate chip cookies.) I really do genuinely enjoy cooking for people but I'm helpless in the face of flattery even when I know it's not a good idea.
Fast-forward to the Valentine's Day party. Anna made it very clear that I was expected to produce a couple of pounds of peppermint fudge, and that to fail to deliver would not only break the heart of every child in Mrs. Anderson's 4th grade class, it would personally crush her AND practically guarantee that she would be a social pariah for the rest of the year. And of course there is nothing that I could (conveniently) purchase that could possibly compare to the utter marvelousness of the fudge. (This is how Mom Guilt works. Ask me about the strawberry cake sometime. Also the Elmo balloon.) Happily, we had the ingredients on hand and it really wasn't that big a deal to actually make the fudge. But here's where I got stupid: this being Valentine's Day, I was thinking how cute it would be to cut the fudge into little heart shapes and put them in individual cupcake liners and pipe a little pink heart on each one.
Regrettably, the heart-shaped fondant cutter is just a little teeny bit shorter than the fudge; if you've ever has this experience you know that it's never as easy as just pushing harder so the fudge (or cookie dough or whatever) comes out the top of the cutter, because everything is sticky or slippery or messy in some way. Also your hands get very inconveniently in the way. I figured that if I whacked it with the flat end of the meat tenderizer the cutter goes all the way to the bottom of the fudge so I don't have to cut that jaggedy edge off. Good. But now the cutter is embedded in the cold fudge, and I can't remove it without making a giant mess and getting telltale fingerprints all over the fudge. Also I'm not entirely sure that this is going to work out to 24 pieces so I'm trying not to waste any. Hmm. OK. Pliers. Pliers will do the trick.
This would have all been much funnier if it wasn't 6 a.m. on the morning of the party. Yes, I should have started earlier but no, I didn't; it's been a busy week and drinking a bottle of wine and watching 4 episodes of Downton Abbey last night was much more important for my mental well-being. So here I am, whacking the cookie cutter with a mallet and pulling it out with pliers and making every little damn heart-shaped piece of damn fudge damn perfect in its individual color-coordinated damn cupcake liner. There are chocolate handprints all over my coffee cup. It's just too early for this. Screw the little pink icing hearts. Whatever.
Fittingly, this recipe is from Martha Stewart. She and I need to have a little heart-to-heart about unrealistic standards, one of these days.
Peppermint Fudge
16 oz. semisweet chocolate (get the mini chips if you can find them)
1 cup peppermint candies (or broken candy canes)
3/4 cup heavy cream (if you only have milk, use 1/2 cup and add an extra tablespoon of butter; it's not worth an extra trip to the store if you don't have cream on hand)
3 1/2 cups mini marshmallows
5 tablespoons unsalted butter
1 1/2 cups sugar
1 teaspoon coarse kosher salt
Line a 9-inch baking pan with parchment paper and spray with nonstick cooking spray. (You can also use a 9x11 baking pan if you want flatter fudge but be warned that this doesn't always work out as expected. Damn cookie cutters.)
Put the chocolate in a bowl (if you're using chocolate bars, chop them up or grind them in the food processor). Put the candy in the food processor and process until finely chopped. Place in a large saucepan with the rest of the ingredients and heat over medium-high heat. Whisk frequently until the marshmallows are completely melted and the mixture is smooth.
Pour through a strainer (don't skip this step) into the bowl of chocolate. Let it sit for a minute or two, then whisk until the chocolate is melted. When the mixture is smooth, pour it into the prepared baking pan and smooth the top. Refrigerate about 3 hours or until set.
IMPORTANT: Wash your pan and strainer IMMEDIATELY. Hardened peppermint candy on your good saucepan is going to ruin your day.
As a final note: I was mobbed by 4th graders when I walked in the room today. They were very, very happy to have gotten fudge at the party, and Anna beamed at me from across the room and did that kid mental telepathy thing that let me know she was really happy and loves me and I'm the best mom ever. So it was totally worth it.