If gluten-free baking has ever made you sad, I have the solution.
I also have several of their single-topic cookbooks (“Sous Vide for Everybody,” anyone?) and they’re similarly excellent, if a little intimidating.
So I half-thought that the copy of The How Can It Be Gluten-Free Cookbook Collection that I was recently gifted with might
be more of the same – I’d page through it, marvel at their precision and
detail, and shelve it right next to the baking-only subset of this book, which I already own and haven’t
touched.
Wrong! So, so, so wrong. First off, gluten-free baking is a
continual source of disappointment for me; but I figured if anyone was going to
get it right it was going to be America’s Test Kitchen. In the “Why This Recipe
Works” section before each recipe, I actually understand the incremental
changes they make; I’ve tried many of these adjustments myself and get how a teaspoon
of psyllium husk, for instance, can make all the difference. Also it was a gift
and I didn’t want to be ungrateful.
So in I dove. The first, crucial step is making the ATK
all-purpose flour blend. The recipes include notes for subbing in King Arthur
Flour’s All-Purpose flour mix and Bob’s Red Mill 1-to-1 Flour Blend, but they
rightly point out that (1) King Arthur’s turns out pretty well but just isn’t
quite right and (2) Bob’s Red Mill stuff always tastes kind of beany. (Try that
nasty-ass Chicka pasta monstrosity if you’re not sure what I mean by that.)
The first recipe I made was focaccia, because I crave it
occasionally and it went well with dinner. The result was almost too fluffy –
something I never in a million, billion years thought I would ever say about something
gluten-free. My advice: oil the sides of the pan, because the dough is going to
rise more than you expect and you don’t want the middle to look sunken when you
pull the final product out of the oven; and pay close attention to the instructions
about when exactly to put the baking stone in the oven so your temperatures are
accurate. John has never had focaccia before and ate half of it. I consider it
a great success.
The next challenge was pie crust. I’ve made the occasional
GF pie crust and it’s never bad; in fact, it holds up better than regular pie
crust in that it doesn’t get soggy overnight. It’s not tender and flaky,
though, and it’s usually a little too gloppy to roll out nicely. Adding bench
flour seems to make it tough.
Naturally, the ATK folks have experienced the same things.
The resulting pie crust was relatively easy to roll out – I say relatively
because I didn’t let it warm up enough before rolling it out and it was an
absolute test of my upper-body strength. I was feeling very impatient. It was,
however, my first-EVER double-crust pie and I was mostly pleased with it. The
crust itself was great where it wasn’t too thin or too thick, because I really
need some practice rolling; I’m going to get it when I roll out the crust for
tonight’s dessert. Because it was so good and so easy that I’m actually making desserts.
They have also thoughtfully provided separate recipes for single- and
double-crust pies so I don’t have to do math in my head, a sure formula for not-nearly-as-much
success (not an actual disaster, but certainly an inferior product).
Flush with success, I decided to tackle the Light and Fluffy
Biscuits. As Anna said, “Holy fucking shit. This is gluten-free?!” which should
give you an idea of how actually light and fluffy these were. They were
amazing. I did notice a little bit of a tang from the yogurt but it wasn’t
enough to take away from the absolute deliciousness – they were just the right amount
of moist, the crumb was tender, they were fluffy; they even browned up! They
were, in short, perfect. If you buy this cookbook for no other reason than this
biscuit recipe, it would be well worth it.
By now my tub of flour mix was getting low. I used the last
cup to improvise some self-rising cornmeal for a squash fritter recipe (from a
different cookbook) (also delicious) (recipe to follow at some point) and now I
need to make a grocery run to fill the tub up again. I’ll be making a double
batch this time, since I’m apparently on a baking bender. I’d also like to try
the whole grain version, as there’s a graham cracker recipe I’m feeling pretty optimistic
about. It would be nice to have s’mores at the fire pit that are made from
something other than Deb Perelman’s excellent cookie cake recipe, which
is delightful but not really a proper s'more.
The How Can It Be Gluten-Free Cookbook Collection from
America’s Test Kitchen. Rating: 5 out of 5. Would definitely recommend to
anyone who’s ever felt sad about gluten-free baking.